Para um resultado mais seguro, envolva toda a sua consulta atual em uma subconsulta.
SELECT p.id, p.name, p.surname,
IFNULL(trop.trophy_count, 0),
IFNULL(pts.points, 0)
FROM dbo.Players p
LEFT JOIN
(
select p.id, count(t.player_id) as trophy_count
from dbo.Players p
left join Trophies t on t.player_id=p.id
group by p.id
) trop ON p.id = trop.id
LEFT JOIN
(
select p.id,sum(points) as points
from dbo.Players p
inner join dbo.Stats s on s.player_id = p.id
group by p.id
) pts ON p.id = pts.id